School Official Who Helped Sick Student Arrested for Fraud

Category: Education/Family

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. superintendent / ˌsuːpɚɪnˈtɛndənt / (n) – a person who supervises or manages an organization
    Example:

    All principals in this area should report to the school district’s superintendent.


  2. bail / beɪl / (n) – payment given to court so that an accused person can leave prison
    Example:

    People with very serious cases cannot leave prison on bail.


  3. lapse / læps / (n) – a mistake or error 
    Example:

    The prized painting was stolen from the museum because of a lapse in security.


  4. out of (something) / aʊt əv / (adv) – because of a certain feeling or reason
    Example:

    The teacher yelled at the class out of frustration.


  5. unanimous / juˈnænəməs / (adj) – having everyone’s agreement
    Example:

    The winner of the contest was announced after a unanimous vote by the judges.


Article

Read the text below.

A high-ranking school official in Indiana was arrested for using her son’s insurance to pay for a student’s medical expenses.


In January, Casey Smitherman, then superintendent of Elwood Community Schools, took a sick student to the hospital for a checkup. Because the student did not have health insurance, Smitherman used her own son’s insurance to pay for the child’s hospital bills.


After her deed was discovered, Smitherman was arrested for insurance fraud, misconduct, and identity theft. She was later released on bail.


A month following her arrest, Smitherman resigned from her post because of the negative attention that she had been receiving.


In a statement, Smitherman apologized to the school board, the teachers, and the students of Elwood Community Schools. She acknowledged that what she did was wrong and called it a lapse in judgment. She said that, at the time, she was only concerned about the well-being of her student.


The Indiana district’s school board showed understanding toward Smitherman, believing that she only acted out of concern. Despite this, the school board quickly accepted her resignation after a unanimous vote.


Outside Elwood Community Schools, Smitherman’s case garnered mixed reactions from the public. A person close to the student’s family disapproved of her actions, saying that they were inappropriate and unnecessary.


On the other hand, a retired police officer said that Smitherman did not really commit a mistake, but an illegal choice. The head of the Elwood district’s teachers union has the same opinion. He recognized Smitherman’s concern for the student but nonetheless agreed that she should undoubtedly be criminally charged for violating the law.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

• Do you agree with Smitherman’s decision to use her son’s insurance to pay for the medical expenses of her student? Why or why not?
• Do you think that it was right for the school board to accept Smitherman’s resignation? Discuss.

Discussion B

• Do you think teachers should help or support students with matters outside of school (e.g. family life, health)? Why or why not?
• Why do you think students ask teachers for help with matters that are not related to school?