US Colleges to Score Students Based on Economic Background

Category: Education/Family

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. oversee / ˌoʊ vərˈsi / (v) – to manage something
    Example:

    She is learning everything about the project because she will be the one to oversee it next year.


  2. adversity / ædˈvɜr sɪ ti / (n) – a difficult circumstance or experience
    Example:

    The team overcame adversity by supporting each other through hard times.


  3. level the playing field / ˈlɛv əl ðə ˈpleɪ ing fild / (idiom) – to make a situation fair for all the people involved
    Example:

    Giving the same clues to all contestants levels the playing field and gives everyone an equal chance of winning.


  4. diversify / dɪˈvɜr səˌfaɪ / (v) – to include different kinds of people or things
    Example:

    The company is hiring people from different backgrounds to diversify its employees.


  5. whittle down / ˈʰwɪt l daʊn / (phrasal) – to slowly reduce the amount of something so that it becomes smaller or simpler
    Example:

    Larger venues are expensive, so I had to whittle down my guest list to just 70 people.


Article

Read the text below.

Students aiming to get into American universities will now be given scores based on their social and economic backgrounds.


The College Board, an organization that oversees the United States’ standardized college admission exam, will be using a new tool called Environmental Context Dashboard. With this tool, students will be scored on a scale of 1 to 100 based on 15 factors, including neighborhood, family, and high school environment.


Scores higher than 50 would indicate that a student is facing great adversity, which may include having low family income or living in a neighborhood with high crime rate. On the other hand, a score below 50 would mean that a student is more privileged.


This scoring tool comes amid scandals that some schools are currently facing. Some wealthy and high-profile parents allegedly resort to bribery for colleges to accept their children. The College Board hopes that the new scoring system will level the playing field between wealthy and poor students, as well as diversify the student population in colleges.


The tool has already been tested in 50 colleges around the United States, and the College Board plans to also implement its usage in other schools. Yale University, which is among the first schools to try the new scoring scheme, is considering the tool a success. The university’s dean of admissions said that the Environmental Context Dashboard has helped the school diversify its incoming freshmen class.


However, some experts questioned the effectiveness of the tool. An analyst criticized the act of assigning numbers to students’ circumstances, arguing that a student’s background and experiences cannot be whittled down into a single score.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

• Do you think the Environmental Context Dashboard will make college admissions fair? Why or why not?
• In your opinion, should the Environmental Context Dashboard also be implemented in your country’s schools? Why or why not?

Discussion B

• Why do you think some people resort to illegal practices to get their children into good schools?
• What do you think can be done to prevent bribery and unfair admissions from happening in schools? Discuss.