California Signs Law Reclassifying Independent Contractors

Category: Top Stories

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. provision / prəˈvɪʒ ən / (n) – a condition in a policy, agreement, or law
    Example:

    Under the contract’s provisions, employees can’t work for two different companies at the same time.


  2. laud / lɔd / (v) – to praise
    Example:

    The company was lauded for promoting work-life balance among its employees.


  3. shoulder / ˈʃoʊl dər / (v) – to take the burden or responsibility for something
    Example:

    The single father shoulders all the expenses at home.


  4. rigid / ˈrɪdʒ ɪd / (adj) – cannot be changed
    Example:

    The rules in traditional companies are quite rigid. Such companies have strict working schedules and dress codes.


  5. deprive of / dɪˈpraɪv əv / (phrasal) – to take something away from someone
    Example:

    The employees complained when the management deprived them of paid sick leave.


Article

Read the text below.

California Governor Gavin Newsom has signed a law that will reclassify independent contractors into regular employees, effective January 1, 2020.


Under the new Assembly Bill 5 (AB5), independent contractors—such as rideshare drivers from Uber and Lyft—will now be considered employees.


According to Newsom, being considered independent contractors is a major reason for the drivers’ unfair compensation. As independent contractors, they are only paid for every ride they complete. With the AB5 reclassifying them as employees, the drivers will be entitled to receiving minimum wage, paid sick days, paid family leave, and unemployment insurance.


Based on the AB5, workers can be classified as independent contractors only if they meet three criteria. First, they must not be under the control of the company. Second, they must do tasks that are outside that company’s usual operations. Lastly, they must do independent work or have an independent business with the same nature as the work they do for that company.


The provisions of the new law could affect approximately one million workers in California. Aside from rideshare drivers, it will also apply to laborers in other industries, such as construction workers and janitors.


The law has received both positive and negative reactions. Many drivers and labor groups lauded it because it ensures that workers are protected.


On the other hand, some companies highlighted the disadvantages of the new law. Lyft’s CEO said that the drivers’ reclassification would entail increased costs, resulting in a higher car fare shouldered by the passengers. Reclassifying drivers into full-time employees would also force them into rigid shifts that will deprive them of flexible schedules.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

• Given the pros and cons mentioned in the article, do you agree with reclassifying independent contractors like rideshare drivers into regular employees? Why or why not?
• What can the government do to address the disadvantages raised by the critics of the new law? Discuss.

Discussion B

• Why do you think some people choose to become independent contractors (e.g. rideshare drivers, freelancers)? Discuss.
• Would you rather be a regular employee or an independent contractor? Why?