Libraries struggle to afford the demand for e-books, seek new state laws in fight with publishers

印刷用画面を開く

Posted

Category: Education/Family

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. grapple / ˈgræp əl / (v.) – to try hard to solve or deal with a difficult problem or situation
    Example:

    The local government has been grappling with the increasing number of homeless people in the city.


  2. haggle / ˈhæg əl / (v.) – to negotiate over the price or terms of something
    Example:

    The tourists haggled with the street vendor over the price of the souvenirs before finally reaching a deal.


  3. modestly / ˈmɒd ɪst li / (adv.) – to a moderate degree; in a way that is not excessive or extreme
    Example:

    The company’s profits have increased modestly over the past year, showing steady growth rather than dramatic increases.


  4. rein in (something) / reɪn ɪn / (phrasal v.) – to control or limit something, typically to prevent it from becoming too extreme or out of control
    Example:

    Parents need to rein in their children’s screen time to ensure they have a healthy balance of activities.


  5. intellectual property / ˌɪn tlˈɛk tʃu əl ˈprɒp ər ti / (n.) – idea, invention, etc., that someone has made and has the right to sell and is protected by the law
    Example:

    As an author, it’s important to understand how to protect your intellectual property rights.


Article

Read the text below.

Whenever bestselling author Robin Cook releases a new medical thriller, the head of the public library in West Haven knows demand for digital copies will be high. So will the price.


Like many libraries, West Haven has been grappling with the soaring costs of e-books and audiobooks. The digital titles often come with a price tag that’s far higher than what consumers pay. While one hardcover copy of Cook’s latest novel costs the library $18, it costs $55 to lease a digital copy — a price that can’t be haggled with publishers.


And for that, the e-book expires after a limited time, usually after one or two years, or after 26 checkouts, whichever comes first. While e-books purchased by consumers can last into perpetuity, libraries need to renew their leased e-materials.


The modestly funded West Haven Library has spent more than $12,000 over the last three years to lease just 276 additional digital titles beyond what patrons can access through a consortium of public libraries. Eighty-four of those books are no longer available. If that same amount had been spent on paper books, it would have covered about 800 titles.


“Imagine if a playground was built at a school with tax dollars, only to be taken down after two years of use,” librarian Colleen Bailie said at a recent public hearing.


Publishers, however, argue the arrangement is fair considering e-book licenses for libraries allow numerous patrons to “borrow” them and the per-reader cost is much less expensive than the per-reader rate.


Librarians in several states have been pushing for legislation to rein in the costs and restrictions on electronic material, which has been growing in popularity since the COVID-19 pandemic. Patrons are stuck on long waiting lists for audio and e-books, and digital offerings are limited.


This year, lawmakers in states including Connecticut, Massachusetts, Illinois, Hawaii and New Hampshire have proposed bills aimed at closing the affordability gap. A bill was introduced in Virginia but was tabled in February.


They face strong opposition from the publishing industry, which argues the legislation undermines intellectual property values and will harm the publishing ecosystem.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • Do you think literary products should be expensive? Why or why not? What do you think are the potential effects of increasing the costs of audiobooks and e-books (ex. decreased interest in literary works, piracy)? Discuss.
  • Should public libraries prioritize investing in digital content despite the higher costs, or should they focus more on acquiring traditional physical copies of books? Why? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • Do you agree that the bills aimed at closing the affordability gap undermine intellectual property? Why or why not? Discuss.
  • What genres or types of books do you think should be more affordable and accessible to people (ex. textbooks, children’s books)? Why? Do you find literary products in your country to be expensive? Discuss.