Nevada jury hands $5.2 billion verdict against Vegas company in bottled water liver damage lawsuit

Category: Business

Listening

Unlocking Word Meanings

Read the following words/expressions found in today’s article.

  1. negligence / ˈnɛg lɪ dʒəns / (n.) – the act of failing to take proper care of someone or something that a person is responsible for
    Example:

    The doctor’s negligence caused the patient to have a more serious health problem.


  2. punitive / ˈpyu nɪ tɪv / (adj.) – designed to punish someone or something
    Example:

    The school decided to take punitive action against students who broke the rules.


  3. plaintiff / ˈpleɪn tɪf / (n.) – a person who makes a formal complaint in court against another person
    Example:

    The plaintiff told the judge that the company had broken their agreement.


  4. reckless / ˈrɛk lɪs / (adj.) – not showing care or concern about the negative effects of one’s actions
    Example:

    He drove in a reckless manner, so he got into an accident.


  5. premium / ˈpri mi əm / (adj.) – relating to something that is of high or higher than the usual quality
    Example:

    The shop sells premium coffee made from the finest coffee beans.


Article

Read the text below.

A jury in Nevada has delivered a $5.2 billion award in the latest large-sum lawsuit against a former Las Vegas-based bottled water company that was found responsible for causing liver damage in customers before it was recalled from store shelves in 2021.


A 12-day trial ended with the verdict in the negligence and product liability case against Affinitylifestyles.com Inc. and its Real Water brand, according to Clark County District Court records. The jury awarded about $230 million in compensatory damages and $5 billion in punitive damages to Hunter Brown and several other plaintiffs.


Attorney Will Kemp, representing plaintiffs, told the Las Vegas Review-Journal he expects Real Water’s insurance company to fight paying damages because the company has filed for bankruptcy.


Affinitylifestyles.com was headed by Brent Jones, who served as a Republican Nevada state Assembly member from 2016 to 2018. Jones and attorneys for the company did not immediately respond to emails seeking comment.


Juries have previously delivered separate verdicts against the company, awarding plaintiffs almost $3.1 billion in June, $130 million in February and $228 million in October 2023. Juries have been told that tests found Real Water contained hydrazine, a chemical used in rocket fuel that may have been introduced during treatment before bottling.


Defense attorneys have cast the company as unintentionally negligent, not reckless, because it didn’t know hydrazine was in the water and didn’t know to test for it.


Kemp represents additional plaintiffs in several more civil lawsuits still pending against the company.


Real Water was sold in distinctive boxy blue bottles as premium treated “alkalized” drinking water with healthy detoxifying properties. It was distributed to stores throughout the Southwest including Nevada, Utah, Arizona, New Mexico and the Los Angeles area, and also was delivered to homes in large bottles before being pulled off shelves in March 2021.


This article was provided by The Associated Press.


Viewpoint Discussion

Enjoy a discussion with your tutor.

Discussion A

  • According to the article, the company Affinitylifestyles.com has filed for bankruptcy. Do you think it will be able to pay the victims the compensatory and punitive damages? Why or why not? What do you think the government should do to ensure that the victims get paid? Discuss.
  • In your opinion, what will be the impact of the company’s bankruptcy on its employees? How should the government help the employees who will lose their jobs because of a company’s bankruptcy? Discuss.

Discussion B

  • Real Water was sold as premium treated “alkalized” drinking water with healthy detoxifying properties. As a consumer, what does “premium” mean to you? Would you buy something that is labeled as premium? Why or why not? Discuss.
  • How do you feel about a “premium” product, like Real Water, causing harm to people? What did you realize from this situation? How might this change your view of premium products? Discuss.